Baton vs a Business Broker: Cost, Process, and Which to Choose

Chat Joglekar
⋅
6 min read
A traditional business broker lists your business, screens buyers, and negotiates the sale for a commission, and is the right choice when you want someone who knows your industry or town and will meet you and your buyers in person. Baton is the better fit for most Main Street and lower-middle-market sellers who want a lower fee (6% at close, no retainer), a free valuation first, and buyers beyond one office’s network.
This comparison is for owners of businesses worth roughly $500K to $10M. Brokers set their own terms, so we use typical industry ranges from neutral sources and say where a broker is the better call.
How a business broker works
Model: you sign an exclusive listing agreement. The broker values and markets the business, screens buyers, and negotiates offers, and is paid mainly by commission at closing, according to the International Business Brokers Association (IBBA).
Commission: typically 8% to 15% of the sale price for a Main Street business, per the IBBA. FindLaw gives a wider 6% to 20% range, and Baton’s site cites 10% to 15%.
Larger deals: the rate usually steps down as the price rises. Many brokers use a modified Lehman formula, such as 10% of the first $1 million and 8% of the second.
Minimums and upfront fees: commissions often carry a minimum, commonly $10,000 to $15,000 on smaller deals (BizBen). Many Main Street brokers charge nothing upfront; some charge for a valuation or ask for a retainer.
Contract: usually exclusive for 6 to 12 months, plus a tail period during which you can still owe the commission if a buyer the broker introduced closes later. Tail lengths vary, and some run as long as 24 months.
Timing: in the IBBA and M&A Source Market Pulse for Q2 2026, Main Street deals averaged 6 to 10 months from engagement to close, and lower-middle-market deals 11 to 12 months.
Baton vs a business broker
Baton | Business broker | |
|---|---|---|
Upfront cost | None. No retainer or listing fee. | Varies. Often none; some charge for a valuation or a retainer. |
Commission or success fee | 6% of the total purchase price, paid at close | Typically 8% to 15% on Main Street deals, often with a minimum |
Who runs the sale | A dedicated Baton advisor, through diligence and close | An individual broker, often local |
Valuation | Free, data-driven valuation before you list | Broker’s opinion of value, sometimes for a fee |
Buyer reach | 30,000+ vetted buyers, major business-for-sale sites, and direct outreach to strategic buyers | The broker’s network and listing sites |
Off-market option | Yes. Free anonymous listing to test interest privately. | Confidential marketing under NDA; varies by broker |
Contract term | Three-month exclusive, then month to month | Typically 6 to 12 months, plus a tail |
Typical time to close | Offers in about 6 weeks. About 6 months from listing to close on average. | 6 to 10 months (Main Street), 11 to 12 months (lower middle market) |
Pricing and features checked October 2026. Baton figures are from baton.com/pricing. The broker column reflects typical ranges from the IBBA, the Market Pulse survey, FindLaw, and the broker sources listed below.
Where the difference shows up
The fee is the biggest gap. On a $1.5 million sale, Baton’s 6% success fee is $90,000. At a 10% broker commission, the same sale costs $150,000, or $60,000 more. A tiered 10% and 8% schedule comes to $140,000. Get any fee schedule in writing, including the minimum.
The second is reach. A broker’s strength is local knowledge, which suits small deals: IBBA survey data from 2020 found that for businesses under $500K, about 70% of buyers lived within 20 miles of the seller. Baton lists on its own marketplace and major business-for-sale sites, and contacts strategic buyers directly.
The third is commitment. A broker agreement typically holds you for 6 to 12 months, plus a tail. Baton’s Seller Plan is a three-month exclusive, then month to month, cancel any time after. Also ask how any suggested price was reached: an asking price the market will not support costs you months.
Which should you use?
Choose a business broker if a broker near you has a strong record selling businesses in your industry or town, your likely buyers are local (common for smaller Main Street businesses), you want in-person meetings with your advisor and buyers, or you are selling outside the U.S., where Baton does not yet operate.
Choose Baton if you want a 6% fee with no retainer, a free valuation before you commit, a short exclusive term, and buyers beyond your local market, with SBA and bank pre-qualification for interested buyers. Baton focuses on businesses worth $500K to $100M.
Start with a number
Know what your business is worth before you discuss fees with anyone. Get a free Baton valuation.
FAQ
Do I need a business broker to sell my business? No. You can sell on your own, hire a broker, or use an advisory platform such as Baton, which assigns a dedicated advisor for a 6% success fee paid at close.
How much does a business broker charge? Main Street brokers typically charge 8% to 15% of the sale price, often with a minimum fee, according to the IBBA, with tiered Lehman-style rates on larger deals. Baton charges a 6% success fee, paid only when the business sells.
How long is a business broker contract? Broker listing agreements are usually exclusive for 6 to 12 months. Most add a tail period, during which you may owe a commission if a buyer the broker introduced buys later.
How long does it take a business broker to sell a business? The IBBA and M&A Source Market Pulse for Q2 2026 found Main Street deals averaged 6 to 10 months from engagement to close, and lower-middle-market deals 11 to 12 months. Baton deals average about 6 months from listing to close.
What are the best alternatives to a business broker? For owners who want a dedicated advisor at a lower fee, Baton. To compare broker firms, see Baton vs Sunbelt, Baton vs Transworld, and Baton vs Murphy Business.
More comparisons
See every option side by side on Compare Baton, or read another comparison:
Sources
Baton pricing, checked October 2026
Market Pulse Survey Q2 2026, IBBA and M&A Source
Broker listing agreements, FindLaw
Typical terms in a business broker contract, Murphy Business
Your agreement with a business broker, Website Closers